English

2017-10-27 NSPRM - Plato - Parmenides (hyp5,hyp9) - Working to Understand the Summary Conclusions at the End of Hyp9 and Hyp5

Dialogue(s): parmenides Chapters: hyp5;hyp9 Sections: 166c,160b Attendees: Pierre, Barbara, David, Regina, JulieH, Eldar From Barbara's email to me, when she sent along her recording: Hi, Jeff Eldar should send the chart, added to from yesterday. At the beginning I talked a little about translating most of H9. And a very interesting translation of one part of 9 about the opinion of the many. We actually examined the question of how the conclusion to H9 related to the rest of the hypotheses which led to the question of whether it included the conclusion to H5 which is said to be the conclusion for from H2 to H5. We compared the conclusion of H9 to that of H5 to see what language was included and what, if any was left out. We looked for the language from H6 to H8 to see again how they were or were not subsumed in 9. Pierre asked whether there was different language introduced not included in any of the conclusion and how did that language function. Next time, whenever that is, we're going to examine the relation of H2 to H4 to the conclusion of H5. Nice talk. --------- My own notes as I listened later: [Lots of pocket noise again, apologies. We were still trying it in Pierre's pocket

Sign in with your free account to read, download EPUBs or listen.