English

2018-03-05 NSPRM - Plato - Parmenides (hyp8,hyp4) - More Questions

Dialogue(s): parmenides Chapters: hyp8,hyp4 Sections: 165c-165e (P20-P24), 158b (P15) Attendees: Pierre, Barbara, JulieH, Eldar, Regina 165c P20 additions: "and by appearing to be like.." Comparing the 8th hypothesis here to the shadows on the wall of the allegory of the Cave (in The Republic) 0:16:40 P22 What is a phantasm? Does its origin lie in "the different"? In any universe, if there are 2 things, and one is a phantom of the other, there is a fundamental difference between the two. Why does he add, diverse ? Is he making a distinction between a phantom and what we would call, 'real'? Then the word, 'different', isn't enough, but also a different kind , or nature. 0:39:00 P23 Why does he add, 'each other'? 0:43:00 P24 (last Parm of the 8th) 0:45 PG: It is so interesting the way he describes this group, in the conclusion: Having contact with one another, yet separate from themselves. no mindfulness in this all things possible 0:54:15 returning to P1 and P2 to compare with P24: P24: 'if One has no Being' has been added 0:58:00 JulieH asks about Pou - somehow, etc. Pou probably least likely to be found in hyp5 and hyp9 1:06:45 go to hyp4, 158b (P15), to contrast with what we just

Sign in with your free account to read, download EPUBs or listen.